Art Over Margaritas!: The Battle for Shrimpboat Sound and the Soul of Key West

Two visions square off over Jimmy Buffett’s old Shrimpboat Sound Studio — one led by Parrot Heads chasing art and charity, the other by developers chasing dollars and frozen drinks.

I. The Battle of Lazy Way Lane

There it squats — sun-bleached, windowless, proud — the concrete chapel of sound on Lazy Way Lane, where Jimmy Buffett once captured the heartbeat of the islands. Shrimpboat Sound: a studio turned shrine, a bunker full of echoes and stickers and stories that still hum when the wind blows right.

Now it’s silent again, waiting for resurrection or demolition by margarita. And the bureaucrats at White Street, clipboards trembling, prepare for their next civic séance — because on Nov. 12 at 4 p.m., the Historic Key West Bight Board will decide which dream to feed: art or alcohol.

---

Jimmy Buffett’s Shrimp Boat Sound studio used to be the offices of Singleton’s Fisheries during the heydays of commercial shrimping in Key West. / TEDLUND

II. The Bernsen Doctrine: Art, Authenticity & Altruism

Enter David Bernsen, the barefoot idealist with the real-estate portfolio, trailed by troubadours and true believers — Mac McAnally, Savannah Buffett, Kenny Chesney, Zac Brown, LuLu Buffett, and the faithful ranks of the Coral Reefer Band.

Their offer reads like a psalm to lost Key West: restore the studio exactly as Jimmy left it — no windows, all the stickers, keep the ghosts. Pay full market rent, take no city funds, reopen as a working recording studio and community beacon.

Every note, every dollar, every souvenir sold — all profits go straight to local charities.

They aren’t pitching a business; they’re preaching a revival.

And they speak of turning Shrimpboat Sound into the modern echo of Air Studios Montserrat, George Martin’s tropical Eden where Clapton, Elton, Sting and — Buffett — once made magic before the volcano swallowed it whole. Montserrat was music in paradise until greed and geology conspired to silence it.

Bernsen’s crew wants to bring that heartbeat home — to make Key West sing again before someone builds a bar on the ruins.

---

III. The Hand-Delivered Gospel of Margaritas

Then come the Spottswoods, developers extraordinaire, masters of polite power. Their proposal arrives hand-delivered, sealed like scripture, with a $25,000 cashier’s check clipped to the top — tribute money to the gods of City Hall.

Their vision?

A frozen-drink and margarita bar, part retail “museum,” part blender symphony — history served with a straw.

The delivery itself drips with confidence, that familiar Key West cologne of authority and impunity that reeks of Ramsingh — a cocktail of arrogance, influence, and procedural perfume.

Inside the glossy binder: twenty seats, some fishing photos, a display case or two, and a gift-shop heartbeat. “Cultural activation,” they’ll call it. But make no mistake — it’s commerce wearing a Hawaiian shirt.

They know the rules, and they know the board.

Section 2-774 of the city code? Mastered.

Public-Private Partnership? Filed.

Political gravity? Consider it applied.

“In Key West,” a grizzled Parrot Head said, gazing across the Bight, “art’s what happens before happy hour — and greed’s what happens after.”

IV. Parrot Heads vs. Greed

So the stage is set for Nov. 12 — the Parrot Heads versus Greed, round one before the Bight Board.

On one side: barefoot believers who still think Key West can matter for more than menu prices — the dreamers, the do-gooders, the songwriters who think paradise can give back.

On the other: the blender kings, developers with impeccable résumés and salt-rimmed calculators.

It’s a morality play performed under the tiki lights: Buffett’s disciples versus Buffett’s imitators.

And the betting locals already know the odds. After the UNESCO Creative City fiasco — when the city dropped the banner of art faster than a two-for-one happy hour — it’s hard to imagine the board choosing melody over mixology.

The wind over the Bight smells like lime, tequila, and inevitability.

The stench that smells like low tide?

That would be City Hall.

Rotting from the head down.

---

V. Epilogue from the Bight

As the sun sinks behind Sunset Key, the studio sits in silhouette, its stickers catching the last gold light. For a heartbeat, you can almost hear Buffett’s ghost tuning up — a slow, lazy riff that sounds like the island before the noise.

The dreamers strum their guitars; the developers hand-deliver their checks.

And City Hall, bless its weary soul, will probably reach for the blender switch.

Because in Key West — as in Montserrat before the ash — the music always plays right up until someone figures out they can make more money selling the drinks.

The Key West Bight Board meets Wed., Nov. 12 at 4 p.m. at the City Hall Chambers at 1300 White Street.

---