EDITORIAL | Truman Annex’s pay-to-play pitch is a nonstarter — and a nonstory
A bid to buy the reissuance of expiring Truman Annex transient rental licenses isn’t compromise. It’s a legal dead end — and a distraction from Key West’s real housing failures.
Let’s be clear.
The Truman Annex Residential Property Owners Association proposal is a nonstarter. At this point, it’s also a nonstory.
After months of euphemisms — “partnership,” “community benefit,” “creative solutions” — the quiet part is now loud. TARPOA is offering money in exchange for regulatory action.
That is pay to play.
The proposal hinges on reissuing weekly transient rental licenses that expire by law on Dec. 22, 2025.
Not extend.
Not renew.
Reissue.
That matters.
Under the 2005 settlement that created these licenses, they do not roll forward. They do not vest. They do not linger.
They expire.
When they do, they evaporate into the ether. Legally gone.
Any continuation would require the City Commission to create new transient rights from scratch. The city is under no obligation to do that.
For six months, Above the Fold has followed this story — the legal parsing, the quiet lobbying, the effort to pretend an expiration is something else.
It isn’t.
That’s why this proposal is dead on arrival.
Affordable-housing advocates oppose reissuance. Short-term rentals permanently remove homes from the long-term market.
Hoteliers oppose it, too. Beds sit empty while workers commute from the mainland.
Workforce advocates oppose it because every transient unit is one less home for a police officer, firefighter, nurse or teacher.
TARPOA doesn’t rebut those facts.
It tries to price them out.
That’s not policy.
It’s a transaction.
There’s another truth that keeps getting skipped.
Investment risk is not the city’s problem.
Owners who bought second homes as investment properties — and now say they can’t afford them without weekly rental income — made a speculative bet.
If that bet no longer works under the law, the answer is not to resurrect expired permits to protect private balance sheets.
We’ve seen this before.
During the credit-default crisis of the 2000s, assets were bought on the assumption that favorable conditions would last forever. When they didn’t, the public was asked to step in.
That ended badly.
Key West should not replay that lesson at neighborhood scale.
Meanwhile, the real housing crisis worsens.
Police officers and firefighters commute hours each way.
Service workers crowd into unsafe units — or sleep in cars.
And the U.S. Navy’s failure to replace dilapidated base housing has pushed active-duty service members into the civilian rental market, further diluting the workforce housing pool.
That pressure is untenable.
And it is untouched by reissuing transient licenses.
Once TARPOA framed this as money in exchange for regulatory relief, the conversation effectively ended.
Cities cannot govern by invoice.
Land-use authority cannot be auctioned off every time an organized interest group shows up with a funding plan.
Which is why this no longer merits prolonged debate.
The licenses are expiring.
The law is clear.
The opposition is broad.
The precedent would be damaging.
This is not the start of a negotiation.
It is the end of one that never should have begun.
Key West needs real, citywide housing solutions — not pay-to-play pitches, not resurrection fantasies, and not the recycling of a proposal the law and the public interest have already rejected.